Einstein riddle (2015 version): SOLVED

a5PoA2r_460s

http://images-cdn.9gag.com/photo/a5PoA2r_460s.jpg

This is the revised version of the age-old Einstein riddle (the one with the Pall Mall and Dunhill and all the stuff that 12 year old Asian girls don’t know very much about). I remember completing the old one in year six for fun but a few years on, I’ve forgotten the answers completely.

I’ve been told by mostly everyone that I’m smart for pretty much my whole life (#stayhumble) and I can never resist a chance to prove to people that they are not wrong. In the following, I will go through the steps explaining how I arrived at my answer:

I started with a table, which I used to work out what goes where. The table looks like this

000

Now onto using the clues.

CLUE 9- tells us American lives in the first house CLUE 14- tells us house two is yellow CLUE 8- tells us man in house three drinks water

001

CLUES 4 & 5– tells us red house is directly left of the white house and that the red house owner drinks coffee. The red house cannot be #1 as it is to the left of the yellow house, nor can it be #2 as we have already established that it is yellow, nor can it be #3 as the owner of the red house drinks coffee but #3’s owner drinks water, and nor can it be #5 as the white house is directly to the red house’s right. Therefore, the red house is #4 and the house on its right is the white house.

002

CLUE 1– The British man lives in the blue house so he must be in the centre. The only colour left is green so that must be the colour of the American’s house.

003

CLUE 7– Tells us the American plays XboxOne CLUE 11– Tells us his next door neighbour, the man in the yellow house, owns a Samsung Galaxy S6.

004

A process of elimination tells us what the American drinks: He can’t drink water (Clue 8 tells us the man in the middle drinks water), he can’t drink Coca-Cola because the German drinks it (Clue 3), he can’t drink beer (Clue 12 says the PS3 player drinks beer but the American plays XboxOne), and he can’t drink coffee as he does not live in the red house (Clue 5). Therefore, we are only left with Pepsi and that is what the American drinks.

CLUE 15– The PS4 player lives next door to the Pepsi drinker. Since we’ve established that the American drinks Pepsi, the man in #2 must play PS4.

005

There are three nationalities left: German, French and Swedish. They cannot be in the green or blue houses as these are occupied. CLUE 2– The Frenchman cannot be in the yellow house because the yellow house owner has a Galaxy S6 while the Frenchman owns an S5. CLUE 13– The Swede cannot be in the yellow house either as the yellow house owner plays PS4 while the Swede plays Xbox360. Therefore, the German has to reside in the yellow house.

006

CLUE 3– The German drinks coke. The person in the white house must drink beer because the drinkers of water, Pepsi and Coca-Cola have been established, and the owner of the red house drinks coffee (Clue 5). 007CLUE 12– Tells us the beer-drinker plays PS3 so he must live in the white house CLUE 13– Tells us Swede lives in the red house because he plays Xbox 360. House #1-3 already have the nationalities figured out while the Swede cannot be in the white house as the white house owner plays PS3. This leaves the Frenchman to occupy the remaining house, which is the white house (no jokes about French surrender pls).

008

CLUE 2– Tells us that the Frenchman has a Galaxy S5. CLUE 6– Tells us that the British man is the one who owns both the Nokia Lumia and the PC as he is the only person left with both those slots available.

009

CLUE 10– Tells us the American owns the iPhone 6. This is because the PS4 player (the German) is neighbours with someone owning an iPhone 6; on his right is the British man who owns the Nokia Lumia, leaving the American as the one who owns the iPhone 6.

This leaves us with the solution to the question of “Who owns the iPhone 5s?” As you can see, it is in fact the Swedish man who owns the iPhone 5s!

010

Hope you could follow along with the reasoning and that this encourages you try out more mentally-stimulating puzzles in the future.

Advertisements

15 thoughts on “Einstein riddle (2015 version): SOLVED

  1. Utkarsh says:

    How did you decide to place the British guy in the blue house and why not green?

  2. poopeepanda says:

    The first clue says the British man lives in a blue house

  3. simon says:

    How did you know that the blue house is in the center?

    • poopeepanda says:

      At that stage, we established the location of the yellow, red and white houses. Therefore the blue house (with the British mane) must either be in #1 or #3. House #1 does not have a colour assigned to it but we have concluded that its occupant is American. As a result, the British man cannot live in that house so he must live in #3, which means the blue house is in the center.

  4. jack says:

    how do you establish that the basis of the whole explanation being that the american is in the first house from the left and not the first house from the right?

    • poopeepanda says:

      This was done in a very Western way of thinking: first to last goes from left to right, following the direction of English text. It seems that most commonly, people will begin their numbering from the left. Perhaps the writer of the riddle could further specify this to ensure no ambiguity.

    • Bd says:

      That is not even relevant if the first house is on the left or right. You will just have to flip the table, and you will get the same answer

  5. Josh says:

    Yes I finnaly solved it. Took me an hour. I also made a table and it actually is very similar to yours. My variation however has the nationality on top as the columns and the house number as rows. This problem was frustrating but it so satisfying to solve it!!!

  6. THEJONDOG says:

    Wait . . . seriously, I’m baffled. I got to where I knew the American was in the first house, the second house was yellow, the third house drinks water, the fourth house is red and drinks coffee, and the last is a white house. But your logic states “the Brittish man live in a blue house, so he must live in the center.” That doesn’t make sense. Please, PLEASE explain why the Brittish man, who we KNOW lives in a blue . . . wait, OK, I get it now. SHIT! – I had the blue house narrowed down to the first and center house and if the Britt lives in the Blue house and the first house is American, the the Britt MUST live in the center, blue house. DANG IT!

  7. Luci says:

    Just a comment on the “2015 update” – I think it makes it harder than the original version. While I agree in this day and age changing one of the variables from cigarettes to something else is a good idea… I don’t think this version works as well as it could.

    (A) the names of the phones and consoles are too similar to one another… When I first started working out the puzzle I accidentally thought there was only one galaxy phone as didn’t notice there were two models (GalaxyS5 and GalaxyS6)… The original puzzle had distinctly different options that could not be confused with one another.

    (B) There was no need to change the drinks or pets categories. Pretty much everyone in the world knows what a fish, cat, dog, bird, horse is – not true of phone models. Why swap out milk and tea for pepsi & Coke? Not an improvement IMHO.

    I think it would be better to keep the original and change only the cigars category – maybe make them hobbies (swimming, reading, cooking, football, painting).

    I got the right answer, but only after making some mistakes that wouldn’t have happened if I was doing the original (would not have mixed up clues related to dogs and horses).

    • poopeepanda says:

      Sounds like you could create your own version of this puzzle 😀 I’m not the original creator (not sure who is so can’t credit them directly, unfortunately) but you’ve got a point there with the console/phone names being confusing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s